Young American Jews are Questioning their blind loyalty to Israel

“So, as Jews, if we choose to throw our hat into the ring when it comes to the conversation on Palestinian rights, we need to be prepared to account for who else is out there claiming to speak in our names. We need to remain firm in our commitment to continually opening up space with and for Palestinians to speak on their own behalves.“

Israel and Palestine is not about Jews vs. Palestinians

Samantha Brotman on October 24, 2014

Last night an event called “Zionism & The New McCarthyism: A Conversation with Bruce Robbins” took place in Champaign-Urbana. It was a canceled University of Illinois event that was rescheduled as an independent event, without university support. Bruce Robbins’s short documentary, Some of My Best Friends are Zionists, interviews influential Jews such as Judith Butler and Tony Kushner who discuss the repression of anti-Zionist viewpoints. His talk addressed the rise of a “new McCarthyism” on college campuses which threatens to shut down criticism of Israel under the guise of “civility.” Respondents included myself, Jodi Byrd (Professor in American Indian Studies) and Bruce Levine (Professor of History). My comments were as follows:

My personal experience was very similar to those of the other American Jews in the film: A childhood in a reform Jewish community and a passive acceptance of all things Israeli as part and parcel to my Jewish identity. This came, I should add, from my community institutions, not from my family. Nonetheless, the connection I thought I felt to Israel as a young person was powerful, albeit unexamined. In college, I was confronted with confusing contradictions, then participated in a Birthright trip during the 2006 Lebanon war that catapulted me into a serious examination of my long-held ideas about the Middle East. I began to face criticism from my Jewish colleagues and peers. But I had to keep in mind that this difficult experience of “political awakening,” so to speak – while it was profound for me in many ways – was minor when compared to the kinds of difficulties that Palestinians must face as they struggle to negotiate their places in academic, professional and other realms. I want to be careful to avoid what Steve Biko, writing on the white liberals in Apartheid South Africa, called “claiming a monopoly on intelligence and moral judgment and setting the pattern and pace for the realization of [in this case, Palestinian] aspirations.” So, I am aware that if there is ever to be a just solution in Palestine, it will be, first and foremost, the result of Palestinian efforts. Palestinian voices – not Jewish ones – really do need to be front and center. But this is one reason why this film and the stories in it are so critical: in order to help create more space with Palestinians for Palestinian voices, American Jews need to work diligently at dismantling this notion that any serious critique of Israel is a critique of Jews or Judaism. As a Jew, I am uniquely suited to this role, and it is a role I am still trying to figure out how best to fill.

Bearing this in mind, I have approached with cautious determination questions about Zionism as a movement, about American political support for the state of Israel, and about my role as an American Jew in this discussion. My questions have led me, for the most part, to more questions. But one thing is very clear: This is not about Jews vs. Palestinians. Looking at it as such distracts from some very important realities.

One important question I have tried to understand is: what historical processes went into and continue to shape the current discourse on Zionism? I have tried to look at what was at stake in this effort to couple Judaism and Zionism and who stood to gain from such efforts. These questions led me throughout graduate school to research the history and current manifestations of Christian Zionism, a movement that actually pre-dates Theodor Herzl – widely considered to be the father of Jewish Zionism – by hundreds of years. The relationship of the American Christian Zionist movement to Jews and to Palestinians – both Muslim and Christian – can be an odd one, at once intertwined with broader political philosophies of the American right, American exceptionalism, notions of philanthropy, and, I would argue, racist and reductive views of Jews, Palestinians and “The Holy Land”. Today, Christians United for Israel is the largest pro-Israel organization in the United States and boasts of strong connections at the highest levels of American politics.

I introduce this topic here to illustrate my point that the discussion surrounding Israel and Palestine is not about Jews vs. Palestinians. Zionism is not even strictly a Jewish ideology. Yet, so many Jews see Israel’s relative success over the past 70 years as a result of a Jewish moral righteousness. They see an Israeli David vs. the Goliath of the rest of the world. So many believe that Israel needs to exist first and foremost to ensure Jewish survival. All of these ideas serve to silence critical Jewish voices and all of these ideas share the same blind spot: they fail to recognize that so many others out there have something at stake in Israel’s success that has little or nothing to do with protecting Jews from another Nazi Holocaust, nothing to do with ensuring human rights for Palestinians, and that these people are very powerful.

So, as Jews, if we choose to throw our hat into the ring when it comes to the conversation on Palestinian rights, we need to be prepared to account for who else is out there claiming to speak in our names. We need to remain firm in our commitment to continually opening up space with and for Palestinians to speak on their own behalves. We can do this by chipping away at the tired Zionist tropes so often used to silence them. This film is an important step in that direction. I hope it serves as a catalyst to action for others who may identify with the experiences recounted within it. For me, watching the film was cathartic and has certainly inspired me to work harder to establish a Jewish community here in Champaign-Urbana where anti- and non-Zionist views are accepted and even championed.

I am very flattered to have been invited to speak alongside the others here. And I would like to extend a special thank you to Dr. Bruce Robbins for his work on this very important topic.

 

I’M A TRUER JEW – Moshe Menuhin

Moshe Menuhin, memories of palestine 1904 1913, P 1

Published on Jul 30, 2015

Moshe Menuhin ca. 1913

 

Moshe Menuhin, memories of palestine 1904 1913, P 2

Published on Jul 30, 2015

Second row, extreme left

 

Moshe Menuhin, memories of palestine 1904 1913, P 3

Published on Jul 30, 2015

with grandson Gerard, ca. 1950

 

Moshe Menuhin, memories of palestine 1904 1913, P 4

Published on Jul 30, 2015

Moshe Menuhin, ca. 1975

 

Why Isn’t Palestine A State Yet?

Published on May 21, 2015

Subscribe! http://bitly.com/1iLOHml

With 135 UN members who acknowledge its independence, Palestine still lacks recognition from the US and Israel. So what’s the deal? Why isn’t Palestine a state?

Learn More:

Map: Which Countries Recognize Palestine in 2014?

http://www.polgeonow.com/2014/12/map-…

“Palestine declared independence in 1988, and its government continues to pursue recognition as a country today.”

Primer on Palestine, Israel and the Arab-Israeli Conflict

http://www.merip.org/primer-palestine… 

“The conflict between Palestinian Arabs and Zionist (now Israeli) Jews is a modern phenomenon, dating to the end of the nineteenth century.”

Palestine

http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/t…

“Palestine area of the eastern Mediterranean region, comprising parts of modern Israel and the Palestinian territories of the Gaza Strip (along the coast of the Mediterranean Sea) and the West Bank (the area west of the Jordan River).”

Key Maps

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/shared/spl/hi…

“At the heart of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is a dispute over land and borders.”

Why Jerusalem Matters To Palestine & Israel

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UOfdE…

 

Nazareth Palestine in 1920

Published on Oct 20, 2016

 

In Palestine Today (1938)

Published on Apr 13, 2014

No title, paperwork reads – in Palestine today. British troops keep order.

M/S of a Guard looking out over Jerusalem. Various L/S’s of Jerusalem. M/S of forces lining up, M/S of an armoured car. Various shots as they drive along to Bethlehem. M/S of military vehicles. Various shots as people coming into the city are searched for weapons. M/S of British tanks driving through. A man looks through a slit in the wall.

Various shots as people are searched and have their papers checked. M/S as men walk down the street and cover their eyes from the camera. Various shots of the Arab bazaars which have reopened. M/S as tank drives through. M/S of soldiers at the Wailing Wall. C/U of smiling British soldier. Various shots of Jewish people at the Wailing Wall. Various shots of sandbags, and soldiers standing by.
FILM ID:991.08

A VIDEO FROM BRITISH PATHÉ. EXPLORE OUR ONLINE CHANNEL, BRITISH PATHÉ TV. IT’S FULL OF GREAT DOCUMENTARIES, FASCINATING INTERVIEWS, AND CLASSIC MOVIES. http://www.britishpathe.tv/

FOR LICENSING ENQUIRIES VISIT http://www.britishpathe.com/

 

War In Palestine. Arab Side AKA War In Palestine (1948)

Published on Apr 13, 2014

Unused / unissued footage – dates and locations may be unclear / unknown.

 

Palestine Story (1948)

Published on Apr 13, 2014

Haifa and Tel Aviv, Israel / Palestine

 

Last British Troops Leave Palestine (1948)

Published on Apr 13, 2014

Haifa, Israel / Palestine

 

Military Demonstration In Israel (1948)

Published on Apr 13, 2014

Tel Aviv, Israel.

 

Full Recording – Israeli Declaration of Independence

Published on Nov 8, 2011

Israeli Declaration of Independence as read by David Ben Gurion in Tel Aviv
The following day, the 1948 war started with all neighboring arab countries sending thier armies to stop the foundation of a Jewish State.
When the war ended Jordan occupied the west-bank and Egypt occupied gaza strip. Both Jordan & Egypt did not allow the founding of a Palestinian State under thier rule.

 

1948 “The birth of a new specimen of human being”

Published on May 6, 2011

On 14 May 1948 the Zionist state of Israel declared itself to be in existence. Before and after that event most of the Arabs of Palestine were dispossessed of their land and their rights. How did it happen? a 40 minutes documentary presented by Alan Hart.

Alan Hart is a former ITN and BBC Panorama foreign correspondent who covered wars and conflicts wherever they were taking place in the world and specialized in the Middle East. Author of Zionism: The Real Enemy of the Jews.

Alan Hart’s Website: http://www.alanhart.net